1Password

Left 1Password after many years because Safari autofill and app integration kept failing, and support blamed everything else.

“I have grown tired of waiting for 1Password to reliably work as the password manager it's supposed to be”

Has used 1Password for a very long time and loves it.

“How do you feel after being sherlocked by Apple? Did you feel like it was inevitable or was it a shock? Or kind of both? Not trolling, I'm sincerely curious.”

Having used LastPass and Dashlane, finds 1Password superior overall, though Google's autofill often pre-empts it on Android.

“I've used LastPass and Dashlane, and I feel 1Password is superior overall.”

1Password's auto-submit retried a failing bank login ten times in seconds and got their account locked.

“I had bank internet account locked because 1P tried and failed 10x times within like few seconds, had to disable this option”

Uses 1Password's SDK to embed secrets in homelab shell scripts without leaking them.

“But the SDK is awesome for homelab use. I can embed secrets inside shell scripts without leaking them. It's like hashicorp vault lite”

1Password works across their Apple, Android and Windows devices and its family wallet beats iCloud Keychain.

“1Password fits the bill nicely. Family wallet is also much better on 1Password that’s on iCloud Keychain IMO”

With Mac, iOS, Windows and Android, 1Password is the only option for them.

“I got Mac + iOS + Windows + Android, so 1Password is really the only way for me to go”

1Password autofills a login with name, password, mobile and child's name fields.

“I have a login that requires Name, Password, Mobile, Child’s Name. 1pass will autofill. iCloud would require a manual stored note”

Can record their Google sign-in sites in 1Password, unlike Apple Passwords.

“I have many sites where I use a single sign-on with Google. I can record all these sites in 1Password. Not so with Apple Passwords”

1Password's Windows app crashes at every startup and sometimes won't save passwords elsewhere.

“It has become unreliable garbage. The windows app crashes every time I turn on my computer. The other platforms I use it with, 1Password sometimes refuses to save passwords. It”

1Password keeps prompting to save on sites like Microsoft's even when logins are already saved.

“1Password prompts way too often on certain sites like within Microsoft to save in 1Password. The extension needs work to be more aware sites are already saved and would pop up less”

Fixing 1Password's Safari extension by toggling the app integration only works temporarily, several times a day.

“toggling that setting off then back on seems to fix it temporarily, but having to do that multiple times per day is a huge PITA”

1Password's 'Use Suggested Password' bar is so clumsy they close it and save passwords manually.

“using the dickbar options is clumsy, to the point that I just close it and select and save my password manually”

1Password's extension offers a Fastmail masked email on only about half of sign-up forms for them.

“Why is the 1Password extension so flaky in offering to generate a Fastmail “masked email”? On some sites it will offer to generate one, but on at least 50% of”

1Password's Fastmail integration works decently but often forgets the connection until they log back in.

“it often "forgets the integration" and I need to log back in full-scale to 1P, re-connect to FM, then I can use it again for a bit. Great. but VERY annoying”

1Password's auto-submit breaks many sites for them, and disabling it breaks OTP autofill.

“Since you rolled out auto submit, it breaks a lot of websites. While there is an option to disable auto submit, it breaks auto fill of MFA OTP codes 🤦‍♂️”

Generally very happy with 1Password at work and home, but its Safari extension is slow and janky with multiple profiles.

“Long time 1Password user here, been generally very happy with the product and how polished it is overall. Use it both at work and for my personal passwords.”

As a new customer on Android 14, 1Password demands the password every time they close the app and fingerprint unlock works only randomly.

“I am sick of having to enter my password on Android (14 and Beta App is that matters) every time I close the App even after changing settings to Never”

1Password's browser autofill keeps degrading for them, with OTP codes failing on Twitter, Reddit, YNAB and others.

“There is a constant degradation in the browser autofill experience. I am seeing more and more websites where the OTP codes are no longer delivered reliably (Twitter, Reddit, YNAB, AdGuard, etc.”

A long-time 1Password user who switched from Safari to Chrome because the extension kept crashing and support went in circles.

“had to switch from Safari to Chrome on my Mac because of the issues I was having with 1Password. The browser app crashes regularly, and I got nowhere when reporting”

After a decade on 1Password its performance is abysmal even on a maxed-out MacBook Pro, with sluggishness and unresponsiveness.

“I’ve been using 1Password for over a decade and the performance keeps getting worse. I’m on a maxed out, top of the line MacBook Pro and 1Password’s performance is abysmal.”

A 1Password lock bug on their Galaxy S22 Ultra has gone unfixed for months after they reported it.

“unlocking the phone with finger print doesn't cause 1pass to lock. It's been well over a couple of months now since I brought this issue up and it's still annoyingly occurring”

Managing family passwords in 1Password forces them to create a shared vault for every pairing, which is messy.

“I have to create a separate vault for my parents in the following way just so that they don't have to manage their passwords themselves:”

Sharing a login between their personal and work 1Password users means duplicating it and updating both copies.

“the only way to effectively share between them requires a duplicate/copy of the entry from the personal vault being made in the work vault. But then I have two of”

1Password on mobile still frustrates them: frequent master-password prompts and clunky iOS Safari autofill that seldom works.

“The experience on mobile still sucks, after all these years. Much of this is due to device limitations, but for the love of everything that is holy, please limit the”

Testing 1Password for easy family use and management, and it's working well so far.

“I am testing 1password out now because I need something that is easy for the family to use and for me to manage.”

Has used 1Password ever since their employer provided it, and it works well.

“I've used it ever since, and it works well. I don't mind paying for the software; the folks developing it spend time on the program and should be paid accordingly.”

Having used both, they find 1Password's UI and search filters much more intuitive than Bitwarden's.

“Not to be stickler, imo this drives my point home that 1pass has a superior UI/UX design; maybe it’s a flaw in how I think, butI had no clue bitwarden”

After using both, finds 1Password's UX better than Bitwarden's.

“After using both 1Pass and Bitwarden, I can say 1Pass has better UX”

Years on 1Password: responsive support and it runs on nearly everything except Quest.

“I've been using 1P for years, I'm happy to pay for it because if you aren't paying for it with cash, you're paying for it some other way. Their support”

Loves 1Password but its Android integration is sometimes infuriating.

“so is the android integration.. i love 1pw and idk if its their fault but my god is it infuriating sometimes”

Left 1Password because it's expensive, moving to Bitwarden and then KeePass.

“I used to use 1Password but man it's expensive. I switched to Bitwarden and a selfhosted solution but I decided to completely switch to Keepass”

Three years on 1Password and it's been flawless.

“Ive used 1password for 3 years and it’s been flawless for me”

Finds 1Password well worth its modest annual fee as the best password manager available.

“1Password is great. It’s well worth the minimal annual fee for the best password manager on the market”

Still happily uses 1Password, but has noticed more bugs, sluggishness and an erratic browser extension.

“I still happily use 1Password as the best option and well worth the money, but I’ve noticed a meaningful increase in bugs, general sluggishness, and times the browser extension behaves idiosyncratically”

Running 1Password Business for 150+ users, it's great when it works, but Mac/iOS clients have minor problems and Windows more.

“I'm an admin for +150 users on business license. 1Password is great when it works, but the clients on Mac and iOS has some minor problem - on Windows more so”

1Password's re-verification after clearing the cache is awful for them.

“1password is gawd aweful when it decides to verify who you are after you clear casche”

Left 1Password when it moved to subscriptions and dropped browser support for the old client.

“Once they went to subscription and removed browser support for the old client I left them”

1Password's cross-platform rewrite feels buggy and memory-hungry, and with subscription pricing they're moving to Apple Passwords.

“So they could make a cross platform app which is buggy, a memory hog, and doesn’t feel like a Mac App anymore”

Since 1Password 8 it mostly works but failures are painful and the iOS extension is worse than desktop; still their best fit.

“it mostly works but when it doesn't it's a huge pain, issues started with 1password 8. The iOS extension is way worse than the desktop version for me”

Bought a 'lifetime' 1Password licence that became a subscription, and stopped using it as updates made it worse.

“Bought the lifetime version which ended up not being lifetime and they switched to a subscription system. I stopped using them because the software got worse and worse with various updates”

Moved from LastPass to 1Password this year, but Android autofill fails more than half the time.

“1Password sucks on Android. Auto fill is enabled, but doesn't work more than half the time”

Has used 1Password since version 6 without issues and values its many item categories and support.

“use them since 1Password 6 never had any issues and only password manager that has so many categories which in my use case makes it so much more useful”

A paying 1Password member for about eight years who finds its user experience steadily getting worse.

“1password app has steadily gone down in user experience. I am just hoping that their security sucks less than their UX.”

Pays for 1Password Families and finds it great, but it can't set which field gets the password and support is a bot.

“Honestly it’s a great app and service. I pay for family. But they’ve gotten lazy and moved into the “just print money” phase and stopped innovating.”

Switched from LastPass after its breach; 1Password's import tool and inexpensive plan made it seamless.

“With 1Passwords inexpensive annual plan, good track history, and LP -> 1P import tool, it made the switch a no brainer and seamless”

Has used 1Password for years, finds it great and got family members onto it.

“I’ve used 1Password for years now. It’s great. I had several family members install it over Christmas”

Six months into 1Password and it's been awesome for them.

“I’m only 6 months in and it’s been awesome for me too”

A 1Password user since 2008 who found version 8's interface worse and reverted to version 7.

“I've been using 1Password since 2008 and, for me, version 8 is a whole lot different interface-wise and not in a good way.”

1Password's Safari extension update forces an unskippable, uncompletable tutorial on every new tab.

“I’m currently dealing with their safari extension update whereby it tries to get you to do a tutorial but you can’t actually skip it, nor can you complete it. So”

Still uses 1Password 7 and it works fine on macOS and iOS.

“I’m still using 1P 7. Still works fine on macOS and iOS”

1Password email support takes hours or days to respond.

“My biggest complaint is service. Takes hours if not days to get response via email”

1Password transformed their IT work and has been very important to their company.

“1pass absolutely changed my IT world. Absolutely worth the money, which isn’t that much for the convenience and features. It’s been unbelievable important to our company IT”

1Password in Chrome is hard to use; finding settings took ages and the chatbot gave no direct links.

“i use this on chrome and this is too way too hard to use. it is so hard to find anything and chatbot would only tell u what to do”

After years on 1Password, cancelling cut access immediately despite three paid weeks left, and it was glitchy.

“I canceled and they immediately stopped my subscription, even tho I'm paid up for another 3 weeks. Now I can't login after canceling, so oh well they're dead to me”

Cancelled 1Password because it still lacks emergency access and support is a chatbot loop.

“they do not offer a digital legacy feature like 'emergency access' where you designate someone to request access to your account and as long as you don't deny that access”

Tried 1Password but went back to Bitwarden; masked email and cards need outside accounts and re-entering the password every 300 hours.

“I just gave 1Password a try and went back to Bitwarden. I was looking for the option to send masked emails, virtual credit card numbers and have an easy to”

1Password's Firefox extension now needs repeated clicks and its authenticator codes fail on Notion.

“As of a few weeks ago, the 2fa won't work at all. No matter what code the 1P authenticator provides, it fails to sign in”

Their 1Password passkey stopped working on every device, support hasn't replied and the AI bot is useless.

“My passkey isn’t working and I can’t use the app on any device. I have recovered the account twice and emailed support on Friday. I still haven’t received a response. The AI support bot is useless”

Finds 1Password's app good and its service one of the best.

“That said the app is good and the service is one of the best one. Don’t believe inflated ratings”

1Password was hard to sign in to and only worked sometimes, so they're moving on.

“Hard to sign in to. Sometimes works, sometimes it doesn't. I'm tech savvy and had a REAL HARD time getting it to work. Moving on”

After updating passwords in 1Password on Windows they couldn't access their accounts and the phone app didn't work either.

“I subscribe, happy to pay money for security but JFC just make it work and update passwords. I stupidly just went it and changed to new PWs and then every”

A company trial of 1Password was buggy with Chrome key transfer; LastPass's Entra SSO was far better.

“Started trialling it for our company but seems so buggy with the Chrome encryption key transfer. Issue after issue. Honestly think LastPass is better and that’s what we were looking”

1Password constantly glitches for them and isn't business-friendly.

“Constantly glitches, not business friendly at all. Ranked lowest because its not that good and not worth the price”

1Password generated a password and then didn't save it.

“It just issued a password and didn't save. HOW do you create a product this bad”

1Password works for a single user but doesn't scale for granular sharing across groups.

“1Password works OK for a single user managing many passwords.”

Put their mother on 1Password Families, and a shared default vault makes helping her easy.

“I also put my mom on 1P families with me. It was helpful for us to use the same platform so I could more easily troubleshoot for her. Furthermore, her”

Manages their whole family, small business and volunteer work in 1Password and can't live without custom fields.

“For me, it has to be 1Password. I mange an entire family, both immediate as well as some extended, as well as my own small business and some volunteer gigs”

Moved from 1Password to Apple Passwords and finds the paper cuts gone.

“All of the paper cuts I had with 1Password have gone and I find it a much smoother app”

When their phone and PIN were stolen, 1Password's extra password/Face ID layer was a comfort.

“Having had my phone and pin stolen at gunpoint, the secondary protection of 1Password was a comfort”

1Password's SSH agent and Kubernetes Operator alone make it worth it for them.

“Ssh agent and Kubernetes Operator alone makes 1password worth it. I hope 1P team continues to improve developee tools. Such an amazing feature”

Uses 1Password across Windows, Mac, Linux, Android and iOS, values its SSH key integration and has their family on it.

“I used Windows, Mac, Linux, android and IOS and the SSH key integration is really nice for me. I have my family on my families subscription”

1Password's SSH key features make it a no-brainer for them.

“Don’t forget the ssh key functionality, makes 1PW a no brainer for me”

The latest 1Password 7 update killed the classic browser plugin; they're trying the newer extension, which has pros and cons.

“with the latest update of 1P7 the classic plugin is now defunct”

Still runs 1Password 4, which does everything they need, but the extension shutdown is pushing them to a subscription.

“I am literally still running 1pass 4 and it does everything i need to but the extension not working is about to force me to a sub model”

Finds 1Password 8's interface worse than 7 for their use, but its support is responsive.

“for my use case it is very much not, but it may be much better for others. I see the company respond here, so at least they care about their”

Has paid about $50 a year for a 1Password family account since 2016 and considers it a bargain.

“Since 2016 I've been paying around $50/year for a family account. My original purchase I could find for the iPhone app was in 2008, but everything is showing as free”

A very satisfied 1Password customer for over a decade who stays on version 7 to keep local vaults.

“I’ve been a very satisfied customer of 1PW for over a decade. Like customers, every network is unique, and I have some differences I prefer over a “standard” configuration”

1Password 8 dropped 1Password Mini; its Quick Access replacement is far worse for them.

“Quick access is complete crap. My #1 use case for 1Password Mini was to generate a new password, for a new site, and quickly have it saved. Do that with”

After 13+ years and many family licences, 1Password's forced subscription is pushing them to switch.

“I've been using 1p for more than 13 years now, I don't know how many family licenses I bought, and how many people I referred to it, but this is”

1Password 7 was their last purchase; forced subscriptions and cloud-only vaults drove them off.

“1password 7 was the last time I will ever financially support that company. Not only are the subscriptions a slap in the face to their many long time paying customers”

Hasn't moved to 1Password 8 because it lacks saved Smart Folders.

“That single missing feature is why I have not migrated :-(”

With 1Password still subscription-only and without iCloud/Dropbox sync, they're exploring other password managers.

“I looked to see if there had been any changes to the subscription-only or no iCloud/Dropbox sync deal breakers (for me) and I don’t see any. I guess it’s time for me to explore other options”

A 1Password subscriber who resents the removal of local vaults that customers still want.

“I am a subscriber to 1Password so it's not about paying versus not paying, it's just that 1Password has decided to remove a feature from their product that their customers”

A 1Password user since the start who paid for every version, now looking at Bitwarden because local or third-party sync is gone.

“I have been a 1PW user since the beginning and have paid for every new version, I would pay for the subscription model if I could continue to keep it”

The 1Password 7 classic extension stopped working on Windows but still works on macOS; an older build restored it.

“and it doesnt work anymore with my windows system. Still working with macos”

Keeps low-risk OTP codes and their new passkeys in 1Password because it works across all their platforms.

“Some OTP I store in 1password for ease of access / risk - stuff like random websites, without any payment info etc.”

Uses both 1Password and Bitwarden; 1Password's browser plug-ins worked better and its UI is a bit nicer.

“I think they are almost identical but 1Password seemed to have a slight edge. The browser plugins worked better for me and the general UI was a little more pleasing. IMO. I use them both”

Keeps family passport photos in a shared 1Password vault for travel.

“I keep pictures of passports in our family 1Password vault just-in-case when we travel”

Tried many password managers; 1Password suits them best with an excellent UI and better Android autofill.

“1Password is the one that best suits me, its UI is excellent, it is very pleasant, the autofill function also in my tests I found to behave better, especially on your cell phone (Android”

Finds 1Password better than Bitwarden in UI, support, apps and speed; Bitwarden's only advantage is cost.

“1Password has a better UI/UX, support, better apps, is faster, and has unique features like sharing passwords with automatically expiring links if you want to share your Netflix password”

Finds 1Password's search within notes easier than Bitwarden's and its support much better.

“1Password has a much easier search within notes feature and a way better support (fewer snarky comments”

Moved from Bitwarden to 1Password mainly for auto-type, which they need as a sysadmin.

“I just moved from Bitwarden to 1Password mostly for the auto-type function missing in Bitwarden. I can't work as a SysAdmin without the auto-type”

1Password has a simple, great UI, multiple vaults and wonderful apps; only the cost is higher.

“1password has simple yet great UI. Moreover it has the ability to create and maintain multiple vaults, and has features like "Show in large type", etc. Apps are wonderful. Only the cost is dearer”

On Mac and Windows, 1Password works flawlessly for them and its Safari extensions on Mac and iPhone work well.

“If you're a multi-OS user like me on both Mac and Winblows, then 1Password is still by far the best experience. Passwords for Windows via iCloud for Windows is a”

Had endless problems with 1Password's Safari extension failing to unlock, and eventually switched away.

“I have had endless problems with the safari extension not unlocking properly, and I thought it was only safari until a friend who works in IT told me he uses”

1Password's Safari extension on macOS constantly asks to be unlocked and can't be, an issue they've reported for over a year.

“1Password is a fucking nightmare to use on Safari for macOS. The browser extension never works for me, it's constantly asking to be unlocked but I can't unlock it so I have to quit Safari and try again”

A happy 1Password user for a decade until its macOS browser extension became a nightmare to unlock and fell out of sync.

“Unlocking the extension is a nightmarish dance of disabling the extension, reenabling, refreshing the page, restarting Safari, and repeating until it finally works. Even when it works the first time, there’s a long multi-second delay”

Long-time 1Password user who moved to Apple Passwords and finds it far less buggy than 1Password's extension and app.

“I'm finding the native solution to be a lot less buggy than the 1Password extension/app, and it's free”

Finds 1Password's Safari extension frustrating junk.

“1Password Safari extension is a Windows app dress up as iOS. Damn frustrating to use.”

Likes 1Password after years of use, but hates the constant re-locking and its buggy Safari plugin.

“I've been a 1P user for years and do like it, I do hate the constant locking and needing to unlock it all the time, plus the Safari plugin is”

Uses 1Password as a digital vault for IDs, crypto wallets, bank info, passports and app keys.

“1Password is my digital vault. I store everything sensitive there (IDs, birth certificates, crypto wallets, drivers license, bank info, passports, keys for my applications and pretty much everything else”

Five years of 1Password via work; keeps using it for SSH keys, API keys and secrets.

“I’ve been using 1Password for about 5 years as courtesy of my job’s perks. Since I don’t pay for it, my comparison isn’t based on features versus price. In my”

Upgrading 1Password 7 to 8 didn't migrate all their passwords, and support never answered.

“when I upgraded from 7 to 8, not all my passwords migrated so I still use both. Any ideas? 1Password has never responded to my help requests”

After testing Apple Passwords on iPhone and Windows, they're staying with 1Password.

“I really wanted the Apple Password solution to be good but its not up to speed just yet. Maybe one day.”

1Password's browser extension often asks for a password while the desktop app is unlocked, and won't unlock their other accounts.

“Desktop app is unlocked but browser is asking for password. Or the dreaded multiple accounts are unlocked in desktop app and browser only has one account unlocked and doesn't want to unlock the other account(s)”

Spent hours on Windows because 1Password's Brave extension stopped talking to the desktop app.

“Just the other day I spent hours trying to figure out what the culprit was. I'm on Windows and it seems the Native message pipe is open, but not transmitting”

On Windows, 1Password's Opera extension makes them enter the password every time, and support just suggests switching browsers.

“I use Opera and when it's raised in the support forums, the techs insultingly suggest to just change browser”

After a Mac or PC wakes from long sleep, 1Password doesn't sync vault changes until restarted or edited.

“1password does not sync the vault until you or restart 1password app or you will add new /modify existing record in 1password on device A. Only in this case it”

Switched from LastPass to 1Password and finds it massively better, though leftover search text annoys them.

“it motivated my switch to 1Password, which is massively better.”

As an enterprise customer, they must unlock business and personal 1Password accounts separately since v8, and support's answer was reusing one password.

“I have a business and a personal account and ever since 1password 8, I need to login to both of them separately. The only solution I get from support is”

New to 1Password Families after LastPass and loves it, but Android autofill is hit or miss and it can't create passkeys.

“I am a new 1Password family user, as I just recently switched from Lastpass. I have two major issues with the service right now, both on Android.”

Everything else in 1Password is great for their agency, but it lacks pattern URL matching for licences that free Bitwarden has.

“It’s not actually possible and it’s my biggest complaint against 1password.”

1Password suggestions don't appear in Chrome on their Samsung tablet despite all autofill permissions.

“I have to constantly keep opening up 1Password, and then going back to the browser to see password suggestions from 1Password. And yes, I've made sure I set battery permissions to "Unrestricted" and all Autofill permissions enabled”

Can't use the 1Password CLI on their Linux server because it needs the GUI to sign in.

“I'd love to use 1password on my server but I can't.”

For nearly three years 1Password's Android app has failed to scan 2FA QR codes on four different brands of phone.

“almost 3 years never fixing issues scan the qr code for 2FA or set up another device”

On iPad, 1Password fails to fill credentials at least half the time, forcing copy and paste.

“At least half the time and possibly more 1Password doesn’t provide the website or app with credentials. Only way to do them is to open the 1Password app and manually copy and paste”

1Password on Wayland is wonky: SSH-agent auth breaks unless hardware acceleration is on, which breaks copy-paste.

“Just adding my vote here for improved Wayland support for 1password on Linux. Right now with Electron, things are a bit wonky.”

A 15-year 1Password user who still struggles with tags instead of folders and wants collapsible tags.

“I’m an old-timer (15 years with 1Password) and still struggle with the switch from folder- to tag-based organization. In fact, I delayed upgrading to version 7 for many years because”

1Password works on every device they use, hasn't been breached and is actively developed.

“It works on every device I use, hasn’t had a breach, and continues to be actively developed”

A paying 1Password customer for years whose biometric unlock has been broken on Android and iPhone for a month.

“Biometrics broken on both android and iPhone for like a month (many user reports). Been a paying customer for years, but with basic features breaking I'm questioning it”

Still finds 1Password miles better than alternatives, but quality of life has eroded: no local sync, non-native apps, intrusive extension UI.

“No local sync, moved away from native apps (especially on macOS), an increasingly difficult-to-completely-hide Ui methodology in the browser extensions.”

Twelve years on 1Password: still worthwhile, but worse value than before, with unfriendly feature and pricing changes.

“I've been using 1P for 12 years and IMO being entirely honest, it's a worse value for money than it was when I first started paying for it. I'm still”

1Password kept inserting itself into non-password fields in QuickBooks; Apple Passwords integrates far more smoothly for them.

“the 1password constantly inserting itself and so many non password fields”

Their family stays on 1Password, though losing non-cloud sync and native apps hurt.

“No non-cloud sync option is the main feature that really kills me that they removed.”

1Password's desktop-browser unlock on CachyOS failed until they added Vivaldi to the custom allowed browsers.

“In fact 1Password desktop <-> browser does work. Just Vivaldi was not supported. To get it working, allow vivaldi in the "custom allowed browsers”

1Password works for them with Firefox on Linux, unlocked via KWallet.

“Works for me wirh Firefox. Kdewallet unlocks my 1p. Websites ask to use password if found in 1p”

In 1Password on mobile the keyboard barely opens and it autofills the 2FA code instead of the password.

“Keyboard barely opens when opening vault up. Autofills 2FA code and not password”

At about $3 a month, 1Password feels cheap for handling their most sensitive data.

“It’s $3 a month if you pay annually. I just checked and it’s so cheap that i thought i was looking at the wrong thing.”

Gets 1Password free through work but finds it worse than others on Mac and iOS and getting worse.

“On mac and ios i find it worse than others and its generally got worse year on year”

Upgrading to 1Password 8 on iOS was hard, and version 8 is worse than it was a year ago.

“They made it way to hard on iOS to be able to update to 1Password 8. Super annoying user experience on 7. 8 is better but still worse than it was a year ago”

Switched to Bitwarden and returned after two months; 1Password's autofill, organisation and SSO support are worth the premium.

“I’ve actually switched to Bitwarden from 1Password and came back after around 2 months. I found the higher premium I pay for 1Password to be worth it in terms of autofill, organization, and workflow”

Left Bitwarden after five years over autofill issues; 1Password's Firefox extension is much better.

“I was using Bitwarden for past 5 years and switched to 1P bc of Bitwarden autofill issues. 1P firefox extension is miles better”

As a developer, finds 1Password's CLI tooling unmatched.

“They can be faster in implementation, but different strokes for different folks. As a developer their cli tooling is unmatched.”

Uses 1Password for CI/CD secrets and SSH keys and hasn't found a replacement.

“CI/CD secrets manager, ssh keys... I haven't find any replacement”

Stays on 1Password for its SSH agent, CLI, built-in OTP, vault sharing, multi-OS support and travel mode.

“There are more than a few that have kept me using 1Password. I love Open Source software but this is one piece of software that I am happy to pay”

Has used 1Password's built-in OTP for years and loves the auto-copied codes across devices.

“I've been using the OTP for a few years and love it. It's incredibly easy with sites since 1PW will auto copy the code to the clipboard, and it seamlessly works across devices”

Coming from Bitwarden, finds 1Password the only password manager worth paying for.

“this is the only password manager i feel is worth paying. Makes my life easier”

1Password is great on Linux, macOS, iOS and Windows for them, despite annoyance at the price increase.

“1pw on linux is great. I also run it on macOS and iOS and sometimes Windows for a non-profit I support. The price increase pissed me off and I’ve looked”

After seven years on Bitwarden, trying 1Password they were blown away by its smooth autofill and interface.

“I was a bitwarden user for 7 years until I decided to give 1password a trial after the bitwarden price increase and was blown away about how smooth the autofill”

Switched from Bitwarden after five years: 1Password's autofill is better, especially on mobile where Bitwarden rarely appeared.

“I used Bitwarden for 5 years and switched to 1Password. The autofill is better, the secrete key is another layer to keep your account safe, and using both apps on”

After Bitwarden, KeePassXC and Dashlane, finds 1Password worth the money despite recent UX annoyances.

“1Password is unfortunately worth the money, although I've been a bit annoyed about some UX experiences as of late”

Finds 1Password's security superior and its UX the best of all password managers.

“superior security, probably the best UX of all password managers, serious player. i'm not gonna try to save 20 bucks a year on a product where i keep my logins/credit card numbers”

With Apple and Windows devices, 1Password is far more seamless for them than Apple Keychain.

“I have an iPhone and a MacBook but also a windows PC at home and a windows laptop for work. Syncing Apple keychain across all of that was a headache, 1Password makes it far more seamless”

Moved from LastPass over security issues; 1Password is very secure and its UX pretty good.

“I moved to 1Password from LastPass due to security issues and while it’s not perfect in terms of user experience (pretty good comparatively), 1Password is very secure and that’s the main reason I’ll stay with it”

1Password gives them stable apps, great support and hardly any issues.

“Stable solid apps and great support and hardly any issues”

As a freelancer without IT, they've always had stellar 1Password support.

“I’ve always gotten stellar support when I’ve needed it. I freelance, so I have no IT department to fall back on—so I always go with options that have good tech support”

1Password works across their Windows, Apple, Android and Linux devices.

“The BIG feature for me was that it worked across all of my devices. (I had Windows, Apple, Android, Linux.) The have native apps and a good web browser. So”

Prefers 1Password for its UI, extension, autofill and desktop quick search/type.

“Better UI and UX, better extension, autofill, and on desktop, the quick search, quick type, thingy”

1Password works everywhere for them; its iOS Safari plugin and change detection are worth the money.

“Safari IOS plug in is so good it’s worth the money just for that.”

Finds 1Password's browser plugin the most annoying and buggy possible.

“if you love the most annoying and buggy browser plugin possible, 1password is the subscription for you”

Tried many free managers but always returns to 1Password for its seamless 2FA handling.

“i always come back to 1password. It just works so well. It's the only one I've tried that is super seamless with 2FA codes, so seamless I forget I even need them for particular logins”

Feels 1Password is going downhill by removing features like WLAN sync.

“1Password has been removing useful features (like wlan sync) and is going downhill”

Thinks 1Password 7's UX was peak and version 8's is trash.

“The 1pw 7 UX was peak UX and 8 is trash. Other people managers haven’t been close to good yet”

Sold on 1Password's shared family vaults that update passwords for everyone instantly.

“The thing that really sold me was the ability to share vaults across family members and have the passwords automatically updated for everyone instantly. Prior to 1Password, my wife and”

1Password has always worked across their work and personal accounts, keeps adding features, and isn't expensive.

“It has always worked for me, it continues to work for me. They've added new features on the regular. They haven't had a major security incident to make me doubt”

Still loves 1Password; the family plan works great for them.

“I still love it, the family plan and functionality work great for us”

Trusts 1Password completely and finds it flexible for a few dollars a month.

“I trust 1Password completely. It's extremely flexible and at only a few bucks a month, not a particular burden”

1Password shows no visible improvements and is getting worse on macOS for them.

“1p is standing in place with no visible improvements, and its even much worsed experience on MacOS. but i am too lazy to switch”

Loves 1Password's SSH key and docker login support.

“I love their dev features. The ssh key support and support for things like docker login makes my life so much easier”

The secret key is the main thing keeping them on 1Password and adds no daily friction.

“The master password + secret key is one of the biggest selling points of 1Password, and the main thing that keeps me with it. For an app that contains every”

Has nearly given up on 1Password's Safari extension and stays only because of SSH.

“I’ve nearly given up on it working for safari and moved to universal autofill. It’s not great, but it works more than the plugin.”

Disabled 1Password's Safari extension because it works so poorly, using the keyboard shortcut instead.

“the whole 1Password extension not working really well in Safari is my primary frustration. I've disabled the extension entirely and have been just using the command backslash shortcut”

1Password doesn't fill drop-down State fields for them.

“My experience is that 1Password does not complete those kinds of fields”

On macOS they can't paste a screenshot into a 1Password note, only attach it.

“You can’t paste an image into the note section. You have to upload it as an attachment. I typically take a screenshot of account codes, and I can right click”

On Android, 1Password's suggested items never show the right login.

“Suggested items for websites that actually show the login for that website. So far there's never a single result. (Android)”

After creating a new login in 1Password, it won't suggest it on mobile or PC.

“i'll create a new login, and then it wont even suggest it for me”

Will move to Strongbox when 1Password 7 stops; version 8 removed features they use daily and forces cloud storage.

“they removed features I use daily, 1PW8 performs no better than 1PW7, and 1PW8 would force me to store what I consider to be the most sensitive info I have”

Already annoyed by 1Password 8's move from native apps to buggy web apps, the loss of local vaults, buggier autofill and price rises, they cancelled.

“I've been annoyed enough by the move from 1P7 to 1P8 (native apps that worked to crap, buggy web apps, killing local vaults), buggier autofill & generally buggier extensions, price rises, etc”

A fan of 1Password for over ten years who grew disillusioned with the latest app release and higher subscription pricing.

“I was already growing disillusioned with the *product* despite being a big fan of it over other password managers for at least 10 years. The most recent major release of”

A long-time corporate 1Password customer who also uses Bitwarden personally finds 1Password much better for corporate use.

“as a long-time corporate 1pass customer + Bitwarden personal user, 1pass is a ton better for corporate use”

Likes 1Password for its integrations: the SSH agent is top-notch and the External Secrets integration has never given them trouble.

“I like using 1Password for their integrations, their SSH agent is top notch and I never had problems with the External Secrets integration”

The last couple of years with 1Password have been rough; recently it crashed for them daily.

“Yeah, the last couple years have been increasingly rough. Recently I was even seeing daily crashes from 1P.”

On iOS 17, scanning another device's QR code signs them in with passkeys stored in 1Password.

“I have iOS 17 with 1Password passkey support and when I scan the QR code from another device, it uses the passkeys from 1Password”

Signed in on Windows with a passkey from 1Password on their iPhone via QR code.

“I just logged in on to a site on windows with a passkey* on my iPhone via QR because of this comment! Had no idea this worked already”

1Password's browser extension intercepts the FIDO2 prompt on GitHub, so they must disable it to use their YubiKey.

“Your passkeys implementation in the browser plugin blocks my Yubikey.”

1Password passkeys never appear for them with Google, forcing manual long-password entry; the beta worked briefly then stopped.

“Passkey never appears when using 1password. Especially with Google. I often have to enter my password manually to sign into my accounts. On something like android TV or Chromebook this”

Uses 1Password passkeys with several Google accounts without issues.

“I’m using passkeys thru 1Password with several Google accounts I have. No issues so far”

With 1Password enabled they couldn't enrol security keys as plain FIDO 2FA and had to disable it entirely.

“I spent 30 minutes messing with it before eventually having to disable 1p outright to get it to enroll properly”

1Password's Android autofill and capture have improved but are still inconsistent.

“Capture and autofill in android has improved but is still inconsistent sometimes. What's the plan for improvement? If the issue isn't easily resolved, perhaps you could add a quick toggle/quick”

On Windows shutdown 1Password sometimes throws a memory access violation that blocks shutdown.

“1Password seems to not close correctly when shutting down windows sometimes. A red dialog with memory access violation appreas right before computer is able to shut down (and blocks”

1Password's passkey prompt slowed them down, so they turned off auto-lock to work around it.

“I am quasi-disabling this by just turning off auto-lock. I have pretty strict auto-lock on the laptop proper so this isn't as terrible as it seems. But still is a”

Daily 1Password user whose custom icons vanish on reinstall, logins often fail to save from the extension, and SSH conflicts with Parallels.

“I have actually experienced quite some problems with 1Password to be honest. So I don't consider it as great.”

Uses 1Password for cross-platform access, easy vault sharing and storing security-question answers with logins.

“Cross platform, easy to share vaults with people, I love I can put the answers to security questions in there with the login (because my answers are lies). Today I”

Uses a 1Password family plan across their Android phone and family's Apple devices so nobody is locked to one platform.

“I got 1password so that we can all be free to change devices and not be locked into one system, if desired”

1Password stores far more than passwords for them, organises better, works on Mac/Windows/Android and lets them segregate family access.

“1password lets me store much more than passwords and passkeys- i have combinations, credit cards, bank accounts, licenses, passports, memberships etc”

Keeps separate personal and work vaults in 1Password so leaving a job means deleting one vault.

“I have a personal vault and a work vault. This allows me to keep accounts I have totally separate and if I leave my job, I can just delete the”

1Password just works across their Windows, Android and Apple devices.

“It just works on various devices. While I have an iPhone, I’m not going to lock myself in particularly with my secrets management. 1Password works on Windows, Android, and Apple”

A billing issue disabled their 1Password passkeys and locked them out of their work Okta account.

“Recently I got locked out of my 1password.com passkeys since there were some billing issues. They will disable the passkey api, and you are locked out basically. I couldn't log into my work okta account”

Has used 1Password for about 20 years for attachments, notes and more.

“Attachments, variety of other things like notes. Also been using it for like 20 years”

Uses 1Password across platforms, stores non-password data in it and values the family plan.

“I can use 1Password across various devices and platforms - something that is not available with Apple”

1Password works on their iPhone, Windows and Linux; Watchtower, OTP, passkeys and shared vaults meet all their needs.

“Platform agnostic. It works on my iPhone, my windows partition, my Linux partition. Watchtower is fantastic. It is my password repository, my authenticator, and passkey. I can have a vault,”

Their only problem with 1Password is support for just one masked-email provider, unlike Bitwarden.

“the only problem I have with 1Password. 1Password, please support more masked email providers like Bitwarden”

Uses 1Password across Windows, Mac and WSL for SSH commit signing and shares credentials with their wife.

“I use cross-platform between windows, Mac (for work), and Linux on WSL (for SSH key commit signing and authentication)”

Sticks with 1Password as more mature than iCloud Keychain, with intuitive family vaults and sharing.

“I stick with 1password because it is a more mature and focused product, keychain access is half-baked and an afterthought. The family plan + sharing via vaults is more intuitive,”

Uses a 1Password work vault and stores licence and health insurance details instead of photos.

“I can also store my license, health insurance info and more in 1 Password. Rather than taking photos like I used to do”

Finds 1Password's cross-platform support, organisation and interface much better than Apple's.

“The user experience available in 1password is so much better IMO. But that shortcut is good to know, thanks”

Runs the 1Password beta at work and finds new features fantastic; it's smooth for 10–20 uses a day.

“we run the beta and it's been fantastic trying out the new features as they become available”

Likes 1Password's new security-question generator and keeps paying for such features.

“1Password also has random security QA generator now. Before, I’d just use password component for security questions but now they have a dedicated security question component which is nice. I”

Their organisation uses 1Password's Travel Mode all the time and it does what it promises.

“People in my organisation use this feature all of the time and it has done exactly what it promises”

Has their family on 1Password and likes its sharing, SSH support, masked emails and hotkey search.

“Apart from good sharing features, I like SSH support, masked emails through Fastlane, good support for different item types, instant search via hotkey on my Mac (I use Shift+Cmd+Space to”

Uses a 1Password Connect server so their homelab automation can access secrets securely.

“I have a 1Password Connect server that allows my homelab automation to access secrets securely. With 1P I have an easy secure place to put secrets and rotate them as needed”

1Password's cross-platform support and functionality make it worth paying for.

“Cross platform. Cross device support. As well as the far greater functionality of 1PW makes it worth it for me to pay”

1Password requires the full password after a biometric change, so they trust it over iCloud for sensitive data.

“If I change biometric (touchID on iPad, or Face ID if someone sees my 6-digit unlock code steals my iPhone), then 1Password makes me enter the full Master Password. IOS”

Got parents over 75, wife and kids on a 1Password family account within a few months.

“I've got my parents (75+), wife and kids all on good password and secrets discipline and behaviors from my family 1Password account. It only took a few months of use for successful WAF and proactive parental adoption”

After testing alternatives to LastPass, chose 1Password for its UX for family and business and has been happy since.

“I went with 1P because I thought the UX would work better for my family and business and was willing to pay the annual cost for a family plan. Been happy with it since”

Switched from Bitwarden after its price hike; 1Password's autofill is far more reliable in browser and on Android.

“1Password has been much more reliable for autofill and forms, both in browser and on Android”